Nicholas Carr
Episode 40, How Technology is Affecting Our Brains
Is technology making us stupid? Are we sacrificing our ability to read and think deeply because of constant online distraction and addiction to smartphones and social media? Science and technology writer Nicholas Carr has explored these concerns in numerous articles and his New York Times bestseller The Shallows: What the Internet is Doing to Our Brains. The news is not good.
A Sonic Journey
Our brains optimize for this digital world of constant distraction and multitasking. We become very good at being distracted, superficial, and gathering information. But, we begin to lose the ability for attentive contemplative thinking.
When the internet was emerging, Nicholas Carr was excited by the possibilities. “Human beings are by nature information gatherers and our minds tend to be attracted to whatever’s most salient or important in our environment.” Carr understood that this could be a wonderful and powerful tool, but anticipated risks. “Technology is either going to solve all the problems with the world, or it’s going to create all the problems in the world.” His research showed that technology was evolving to do both.
According to Nicholas Carr, access to unlimited information is a double-edged sword. While these tools have been beneficial especially for people who have felt isolated, endless amounts of unfiltered information moving past in a constant blur actually undermine deep thinking and reinforce biases. It promotes shallow thinking and encourages people into tribes of beliefs rather than broadening their perspective. The smartphone and social media took this to warp speed.
The constant presence of these devices also has resulted in unrelenting extraction of human attention. We simply can’t help ourselves from checking our phones, our social media, or being on the internet. If your phone is even nearby, it will draw your attention. One scientist described cell phones as a “divisive device of supernormal salience” because it contains so much—our photographs, our social lives, news, entertainment, everything that’s salient or important to us in any given moment.
Carr certainly doesn’t advocate for the elimination of technology but rather the informed use of technology and a balance with real human interaction and deep thinking. “It’s attentive thinking that unlocks the full potential of the human mind. There’s a whole lot of activities that are actually more enjoyable and fulfilling if you do them with your full attention without being constantly distracted by technology.”
It’s a compelling argument for closing your laptop, turning off notifications, and putting that smartphone down—in another room far, far away.
Subscribe
Want to automatically receive each new episode as soon as it’s released? Choose one of the following options:
- For video, subscribe on YouTube.
- For audio, subscribe to Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or Google Podcasts.
Don't miss an episode!
What you’ll learn
- What prompted Carr to investigate the impact of technology on human thinking (3:42)
- Neuroplasticity and how our brains are adapting to technology (6:34)
- The evolutionary roots of human’s natural desire to gather information (8:14)
- How the smartphone has created a divisive “supernormal salience” and what that is (9:20)
- Why social media has become the most addictive technology (10:48)
- Why unfiltered information undermines deep thinking and narrows perspectives (12:18)
- The dangers of endless amounts of communication (15:44)
- How smartphones are undermining human richness of thought (18:31)
- Tips for breaking the cycle of constant technology distraction (24:13)
- When is the best time for children to have a cell phone (30:59)
Resources
RELATED INTERVIEWS